| EdGCM Workshop Guide |
| Education - General | |
| Written by Mark Chandler and Ana Marti | |
| Monday, 06 March 2006 | |
|
Follow this series of web pages to view the text of the guide or download the pdf document: EdGCM-WorkshopGuide.pdf OUTLINE Friday:
THE EDGCM WORKSHOP GUIDE
Historically, Global Climate Models (GCMs) required supercomputing facilities and skilled programmers to run, and this remains the case for the most complex, cutting-edge models. For this reason, GCMs in the United States have typically been developed at the National Laboratories run by National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA), National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and the National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR), where some of the nation’s largest and fastest computing facilities are located. The teams that develop GCMs include scientists from a wide variety of disciplines: atmospheric scientists, physicists, geoscientists, oceanographers, mathematicians, biologists, botanists and, of course, computer scientists. Recently, advances in computing technology have made it possible for some GCMs to run on less expensive workstations and even on desktop PCs, making them available for use in schools and accessible by a broader community of researchers, teachers and students.
This unit will take advantage of this new accessibility to GCMs to learn more about the global warming problem and specifically about the effects of carbon dioxide increase (the major anthropogenic greenhouse gas) on future climate. In order to reach this goal, we will use the program EdGCM, which is an excellent tool for teaching and learning climate change. The numerical model allows students to construct their knowledge around climate change as they explore on their own how different components of the climate system contribute in determining our climate. The use of EdGCM in the classroom also provides the opportunity to students to understand and use the methods and tools utilized by scientists in their research.
EdGCM Cooperative Project: Overarching Goals 1) Allow teachers to run a 4-D global climate model (GCM) on a desktop computer, encouraging students to participate in the full scientific process employed by researchers including: experiment design, running simulations, analyzing data and reporting results. 2) Facilitate collaborations within the education community and between students, teachers and research scientists so that students become familiar with the role that teamwork plays in scientific research. EdGCM Workshop: Specific Objectives By participating in the Friday evening workshop session teachers will be able to: The Scientific Process: A Climate Scientist's Experience • Participants will gain an understanding of the typical scientific process climate scientists go through when using climate models: developing a hypothesis, designing an experiment, running a computer simulation, analyzing model output (i.e. post-processing raw computer data and using scientific visualization techniques), creating written reports in the form of scientific manuscripts (i.e. describing experiment design, results and conclusions using text and images), and publishing reports (to the web). • Learn how EdGCM has been developed specifically for desktop computers to allow its users to become familiar with scientific tools that are normally available only at national labs. Global Climate Models (GCMs) • Participants will gain an understanding of the history and theoretical aspects of Global Climate Models and how they are currently used to enable research scientists, teachers and students to examine earth’s past, present, and future climates. Concepts of Modeling • Participants will gain an understanding of the step-by-step procedures that are used by climate model research scientists in setting up an experiment, conducting control runs, inputting variables, and producing typical output products. EdGCM Basics • Participants will learn what level of computer resources are required to accomplish specific experiments and learning objectives and will understand how to organize a climate modeling unit that fits their schools resources. • Participants will acquire the basic knowledge and skills required to use the EdGCM software suite in the classroom through guided hands-oncomputer activities. By participating in the Saturday workshop session teachers will be able to: Summary of EdGCM Basics • Participants will review the fundamental procedures of carrying out experiments using the EdGCM software suite. EdGCM Exercise on Global Warming • Participants will gain an understanding of how Global Climate Models are used to investigate global warming. Workshop members will set up, run, analyze, and report on basic global warming experiments using the EdGCM software suite. Compare Results of Experiment to 2005 Global Temperatures (Warmest Year on Record) and Create a Report on Findings • Participants will compare and contrast the results of their global warming experiments with the actual observations compiled by climate scientists. • Using EdGCM software, workshop attendees will create scientific reports of their findings that will be published to the web. EdGCM Features for Teacher Use Only: Administrative Features • Participants will gain an understanding of various technical details and administrative procedures regarding EdGCM software installation, computer hard disk usage and maintenance, database backup and security issues. The EdGCM Website: Support and On-line Features • Participants will become informed about the features of the EdGCM website that offer online support for members of the EdGCM Cooperative community through the EdGCM Forums, "eJournal Exchange" and "Simulation Exchange". 3) "GCM": General Circulation Models, Global Climate Models GCMs are Process Models - Simulations are based on fundamental physical equations and, therefore, GCM output is examined not only to establish a Cause and Effect relationship, but to explore the mechanisms by which the Earth's climate system operates. The "Primitive Equations" calculate Temperature (T), Pressure (P), Winds (U,V,W) and Specific Humidity (Q) and a wide variety of empirically-based, or theoretically-based equations are used to "parameterize" other processes (e.g. cloud formation, radiation interactions, etc.). that are not described explicitly via the fundamental physical equations.
In the climate system there is rarely a simple cause and effect relationship between phenomena. Instead, forcing mechanisms set into motion a series of feedback processes that eventually alter the equilibrium of the climate. Often, the feedbacks themselves are more powerful agents of change than the original forcing. Unix scripts, like the model rundeck shown below, are used to initiate climate simulations on supercomputers and powerful unix workstations. They are efficient for scientists and programmers, but they assume a great deal of prerequisite knowledge regarding the computer model and require that the user have significant computer programming skills. ![]() A Rundeck Script for the GISS GCM ![]() EdGCM puts control of a GCM in your hands via point and click interfaces The NASA/GISS Global Climate Model The climate model used by the EdGCM software was developed at NASA’s Goddard Institute for Space Studies (NASA/GISS). This type of 3-dimensional computer model is known as a grid-point Global Climate Model (GCM). A grid point GCM divides the atmosphere into a series of discrete grid cells. EdGCM’s model grid has 7776 grid cells in the atmosphere, with each horizontal column corresponding to 8° latitude by 10° longitude and containing 9 vertical layers. The computer model numerically solves fundamental physical equations, which describe the conservation of mass, energy, momentum, and moisture in each cell, while taking into account the transport of quantities between cells. It then uses the Ideal Gas Law to relate pressure to temperature, two of the most important climate variables. Parameterizations, based on empirical data or simplified physical hypotheses, are used to calculate quantities that are not handled by the fundamental equations, or which occur at spatial scales that are finer than the scale of the model’s grid. For example, plants, convective clouds, and river run-off are all parameterized in GCMs (see below for more information about parameterizations). Global Climate Models Described At the heart of a GCM is a model of the Earth’s atmosphere. There are five fundamental physical equations that are used to describe the evolving state of the atmosphere: the conservation of mass, conservation of energy, conservation of momentum, conservation of moisture and the ideal gas law (to approximate the equation of state). ![]() Fundamental physics equations used in the GISS GCM (Hansen et al., 1983) There are two basic forms of the fundamental equations used to simulate the atmosphere in global climate models. These define two distinct families of models: Cartesian grid point GCMs and spectral GCMs. In a Cartesian grid point model the atmosphere is divided horizontally and vertically into a series of grid cells. The equations are solved for each cell in the grid, while taking into account the transport of various quantities between grid cells. In a spectral model the conservation equations are expressed as continuous functions (made up of a series of sine and cosine curves), which define the global distribution of climate variables such as temperature, pressure, winds, and humidity. ![]() Source: Henderson-Sellers, 1985, A Climate Modelling Primer ![]() The GISS GCM uses 3 standard resolutions: 8 x 10, 4 x 5, and 2 x 2.5 (latitude x longitude). The main components of the atmospheric portion of a GCM are those that represent the atmospheric dynamics and the interactions of the Sun’s radiation with the planet. The dynamics calculations help define the general circulation of the atmosphere as well as smaller-scale eddy circulations, such as the cyclonic storm systems that control much of the weather in the mid-latitudes. The radiation calculations determine the energy balance of the Earth by evaluating the reflection and absorption of solar radiation by the surface and atmosphere, and by the remittance of thermal energy back to space. The radiation calculations in a GCM must take into account cloud thickness and cloud distribution (horizontal and vertical), surface conditions (land vs. ocean, topography, vegetation types, snow and ice cover), and all significant greenhouse gases and aerosols. ![]() Schematic of the parameterizations in the GISS GCM Model II While climate models of varying complexity exist, defining simple vs. complex climate models is not necessarily straightforward. That’s because climate models may be considered more complex if they incorporate additional dimensions, increase the spatial or temporal resolution at which calculations are applied, represent the physics more completely, or incorporate parameterizations that describe additional components of the climate system (e.g. oceans, vegetation, ground hydrology, ice sheets, the carbon cycle, etc.). Perhaps the most important of these “additions” to the atmospheric model are the coupling of the atmospheric GCMs to 3-D ocean circulation models. Ocean General Circulation Models Global Climate Models have evolved over time to include more and more of the physical and chemical components of the climate system. Many characteristics of the Earth that were supplied as boundary conditions in earlier models can now be simulated in the latest models. Moreover, as new scientific studies advance our understanding of the Earth’s physical environment, climate models incorporate the new findings by altering or adding to existing calculations. Ultimately, this allows climate models to describe the climate system in greater detail and with improved precision. Probably the most significant change to the traditional structure of global climate models was the advent of models that coupled an atmospheric GCM to a 3-dimensional ocean GCM. 3-D ocean models have been under development for nearly as long as atmospheric models and some of the most important experiments, commanding the most computing resources, have employed coupled ocean-atmosphere GCMs for a decade or more. However, coupled GCMs have only recently become a standard for use in simulating the broad array of climate experiments underway that study everything from climates of the geologic past to the many scenarios that seek to represent the potential states of future climate. Some of the lag in incorporating fully dynamic oceans into global climate models has been due to the added pressure on computational resources that the ocean calculations represent: the ocean’s cover nearly two-thirds of the surface of the Earth; they circulate slowly compared to the atmosphere, requiring longer simulations; on average key features in the ocean (e.g. eddies, western boundary currents, upwelling, and deep water formation) occur at finer scales than analogous atmospheric circulation phenomena (which tend to average 1000’s of kilometers instead of 10’s of kilometers as with the oceans). On the other hand, much of the delay in developing and applying coupled ocean-atmosphere models was simply related to the fact that we knew precious little about the how physical oceans operated. The past two decades has seen an astounding increase in our understanding Earth’s oceans and how they operate over both short and long time scales. It may be that the ultimate reason that coupled oceans models have become a standard component of global climate models is because they have simply reached a point where scientists have much more confidence in the results they produce. Climate Model Parameterizations Climate models built for predictive purposes would, ideally, be derived entirely on fundamental laws of nature. For example, the ideal gas law (Table 4-1) makes it possible for a GCM to always determine an exact relationship between temperature (T) and pressure (p), which are two critical variables used in the determination of the energy balance and movement of the atmosphere. However, our knowledge of the exact workings of many of the processes in the climate system is still limited. Furthermore, many of those processes operate on scales too fine for existing computers to simulate. Therefore, models simulate a number of the key components of the climate system by using series of calculations that are derived from statistical or empirical relationships between variables. These types of calculations are called parameterizations and they range from simple one-line equations (for example, an equation that instructs a portion of an ocean grid cell to freeze at a fixed temperature based on a constant salinity) to highly complex sequences of equations that describe cloud processes, vegetation, continental ice sheets, atmospheric chemistry, ground hydrology, and more. In fact, many parameterizations are themselves models that are designed to simulate just one part of the climate system. However, when carefully linked to an atmospheric GCM, an ocean model, and other parameterizations, they make up a virtual Earth Climate System Model. Such models, that couple together atmospheric and oceanic GCMs with complex parameterizations of are increasingly becoming the successors to GCMs. How do GCMs represent the Earth? Although the key equations in a global climate model are fundamental laws of nature that presumably apply on all planets, they contain a number of constants that are specific to the Earth. Such values as the radius of the planet, the force of gravity, the mass of the atmosphere, and the R constant used in the ideal gas law, all must be assigned appropriately for a GCM to be representative of the Earth’s climate as opposed to some other spherical body with an atmosphere. However, simply assigning the appropriate constants is not enough. A number of other conditions are required as well: Boundary Conditions: Every GCM experiment must have assigned at the outset a group of fixed conditions that describe features that effect the climate, but are not altered in return by climate model calculations. These specified features are called the model’s boundary conditions. The most important boundary conditions are the description of the land-ocean distribution and the topography. Next, the land surface cover is usually specified, including the locations and heights of continental ice sheets, the seasonal distribution of vegetation, and the location and extent of lakes. For certain types of experiments, particularly those that attempt to reproduce past climates, the annual cycle of sea surface temperatures and sea ice might even be specified as a boundary condition, assuming observations of such exist. However, since it is implicit that anything assigned as a boundary condition is not subject to change by the model, specifying characteristics will limit the overall impact of other changes within the simulated climate system. Initial Conditions: In addition to boundary conditions, GCMs must be initiated with a number of initial conditions. Initial conditions are just as the name implies, the description of the initial state of the model. From the standpoint of the atmosphere, the initial conditions specify the starting temperature, pressure, winds, and humidity for every location in the atmosphere. Though based on observations, small inaccuracies in the initial conditions can lead to unique results as an experiment proceeds. For this reason, critical experiments are commonly run multiple times, with the only difference in the simulations being slight perturbations of the initial conditions. The range of answers in such an ensemble of runs places a somewhat crude error-bar on the accuracy of the experiment. Climate Forcings: Once the initial and boundary conditions are supplied a GCM experiment applies a number of climate forcings that impact the results of the run more dramatically. Usually, one or more of these forcing factors are the focus of the experiment. The best-known examples are the greenhouse gas forcing experiments that describe the increase of temperatures during the 20th century and forecast the global warming that will take place in future decades. Like boundary conditions, climate forcings are also specified in an experiment, but they are often altered so that they change with time, or adjust spatially, throughout the course of a simulation. In this way the effect of the altered forcing on climate can be examined. Again, the most common example are the greenhouse gas experiments that increase the trace amounts of gases such as carbon dioxide, methane, chlorofluorocarbons, and nitrogen oxides. Other examples of forcings that regularly impact Earth’s climate include the dust and sulphuric acid droplets ejected into the atmosphere during large volcanic explosions, aerosols produced by human pollution, or changes in the Sun’s luminosity that accompany sunspot cycles. All of these forcings have been the focus of global climate model experiments and have helped lead to a better understanding of how our climate system responds to change. Climate Feedbacks: For the most part, the direct impact of the above climate forcings is relatively small compared with their overall effects. The reason for this is that operating within the climate system are a large variety of feedback mechanisms, which can either dampen or amplify the impact of the original forcing. While the number of feedback mechanisms, and the timescales over which they act, is virtually limitless, there are three feedback mechanisms that are illustrative of the process, and which are dominant mechanisms effecting global warming and cooling scenarios: the water vapor feedback, the cloud feedback, and the ice albedo feedback. As greenhouse gases increase in the atmosphere they absorb more of the thermal radiation being emitted from the planet’s surface, thus trapping heat and warming the atmosphere. Even for relatively large increases in gases like carbon dioxide, this direct radiative heating of the atmosphere is not dramatic. However, the minor heating has several effects. Two of the most significant are both positive feedbacks, meaning they amplify the initial effect of the forcing. The direct heating of the atmosphere by carbon dioxide causes more water to be evaporated from the surface of the ocean. This leads to an increase in the water vapor content of the atmosphere, particularly in the tropics. The water is itself a powerful greenhouse gas, which heats the atmosphere further, causing more water to evaporate from the ocean setting up a positive feedback loop. Similarly, a positive feedback loop is set in motion as the initial heating of the atmosphere by CO2 (and increased water vapor) causes sea ice to melt and less precipitation to fall in the form of snow. The reduced surface area covered by highly reflective ice and snow reduces the surface albedo, thus an increased percentage of incoming solar radiation is absorbed instead of reflected to space. This then leads to further heating of the planet, and another positive feedback loop. The cloud feedback is thought to be far more complex, so much so that not all climate models agree on the sign of the feedback. We know that low altitude clouds tend to reflect more sunlight, while high clouds have an overall heat-trapping effect, because they are cold, and reemit their absorbed energy to space at a much cooler temperature than the surface. A number of GCM simulations have shown that as greenhouse gases increase and the globe warms low cloud amounts decrease as the warmer atmosphere makes it more difficult to condense atmospheric water vapor. This is a positive feedback towards warming. However, if high clouds also decrease a negative feedback ensues that could mitigate the low cloud change. While there is general agreement among global climate models that the combined cloud feedback is positive, there is definitely more uncertainty and variation in the results. Moreover, there are atmospheric scientists who believe that the clouds produced by GCMs are simply not accurate enough to yet determine the true nature of the cloud feedback. Climate Sensitivity: The National Academy Press defines climate sensitivity in their publication "Climate Change Science" as: "The sensitivity of the climate system to a forcing is most commonly expressed in terms of the global mean temperature change that would be expected after a time sufficiently long for both the atmosphere and the ocean to come to equilibrium with the change in climate forcing." Publications, like those of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), will refer to illustrative simulation climate sensitivity results to describe the expected climate change in the coming decades. For example, the sensitivity of climate to a doubling of CO2 is expected to be between 2 and 4 degrees Celsius, based on a wide range of climate model predictions. Introduction At the current rate of increase, by the time today's high school students become grandparents the amount of carbon dioxide in the Earth’s atmosphere will be higher than it has been at anytime during the previous 50 million years of Earth history. Most, if not all, of this increase will be due to human influences – primarily the burning of fossil fuels in automobiles and power generating plants. Why do scientists care so much about this invisible gas that makes up only a fraction of a percent of the molecules in the Earth's atmosphere? The answer is that carbon dioxide is the most prevalent greenhouse gas on our planet. Its presence in our atmosphere helps make the surface of the Earth warm enough to inhabit, but its rapid increase is likely to lead to globally averaged temperatures that are warmer than any experienced on Earth since before the evolution of the human species. Many people are concerned about how this "global warming" could impact the environment, the economy, and the lives of people all over the world. Scientists therefore, need to learn more about the details of this real-world experiment that we are conducting within our atmosphere. How much warming will occur during the next several decades? Will it be evenly distributed, or will some locations warm more than others? Will the temperature increase gradually, or will there be abrupt shifts in the climate? And, how will warming temperatures influence other climate phenomena, such as rain, snow and winds? In order to explore these questions, and hopefully answer them with a high degree of accuracy, climate scientists are increasingly relying on large computer models of the earth’s climate system. The most complex, and most relied upon climate models are collectively known as Global Climate Models. Global climate models are computer programs that simulate the Earth’s climate system in three-dimensions and are commonly referred to by their acronym "GCM". Computer global climate models, or GCMs, are used extensively in the effort to predict future climate changes, such as the impacts of increasing greenhouse gases, and they are employed by geoscientists to explore the average state and variability of past climates, from the climate of the 20th century to that of the ancient Earth. In addition to their use in forecasting realistic, whole-earth climate changes of the past, present and future, global climate simulations help scientists examine the sensitivity of the climate system to altered internal and external forcings. Examples of sensitivity tests that scientists might try include examining how the climate reacts to random changes in the Sun’s energy output or calculating how much global temperature increases if atmospheric carbon dioxide is doubled. A computer climate simulation allows scientists to isolate individual factors, and then analyze their impact on discrete components of the climate system. For example, climate simulations can help determine the effect of increased CO2 on things that are important in our society such as the average start date of the growing season, the impact of solar variability on tropical precipitation, or the role of ocean heat transport in the intensity of mid-latitude storms. Of course, GCMs are not perfect crystal balls. After all, no matter how complex their representations of climate, the climate system itself is many times more complex. However, they are deeply dependent on fundamental laws of nature (as opposed to statistical correlations) and modern GCMs do an amazing job at simulating observed and historical climate change. Perhaps most important is that they provide us with an opportunity to explore and comprehend the processes of the Earth’s climate system in four dimensions - three in space and one in time. Understanding the relationship between Earth observations and the processes that led to them gives us an improved capacity for prediction, which can then be used to aid policymakers, ecologists, public health officials, natural resource departments, industries or populations effected by climate change, and many others. Weather and Climate: Important Distinctions Before delving more deeply into the subject of climate science it is important to understand the differences between weather and climate. Simply stated, weather describes the changing state of the atmosphere at a particular location over time intervals of short duration - minutes to perhaps no longer than a few weeks. It consists of atmospheric elements such as temperature, humidity, air pressure, wind speed and wind direction, precipitation, cloud cover and cloud types, and visibility. Hurricanes, thunderstorms, tornadoes, blizzards, rainbows, and fog also are a part of everyday weather. Climate, on the other hand, is time-averaged weather and is characterized by statistics that help describe the mean weather conditions and variations at a single place, region, or worldwide for a particular period of time – a month, a year or over much longer intervals. Despite continuing marvelous advances weather remains difficult to predict beyond a one-week period. Climate, on the other hand, tends to be far more “behaved” and thus more predictable. For instance, most of us could fairly easily predict that the next 5 Augusts in New York will be warmer on average than the average temperature of the next 5 Mays, or that next 5 Mays will be wetter than next 5 Augusts. The fact that climate uses longer averages to describe phenomena and that it deals with large-scale patterns which tend to repeat themselves from year to year make it more predictable. However, climate becomes more difficult to predict when forces beyond the normal range of variability alter the characteristic physical responses of the climate system itself. This type of situation is essentially what climate scientists now face, in light of the significant increase in carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases in the atmosphere contributed by industrial growth and associated fossil fuel burning over the past century. Greenhouse Gases: Sources, Sinks, and Destructive Mechanisms The gases in the atmosphere which absorb outgoing emissions of the Earth’s infra-red (long-wave) radiation and then reemit radiation are known as greenhouse gases and include carbon dioxide (CO2), water vapor (H2O), nitrous oxide (N2O), methane (CH4) and ozone (O3) and chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs). What makes these gases act as "greenhouse" gases is that they absorb frequencies that lie in the infrared part of the spectrum, the same range in which the Earth radiates energy to space, allowing them to capture much of this energy. {mostpagebreak} {atmospheric composition table} Carbon dioxide is released from the interior of the Earth through volcanic eruptions, and is produced by animal respiration, soil processes, combustion of carbon compounds and oceanic evaporation. Concentrations of CO2 are continuing to rise because of anthropogenic (human produced) emissions from the burning of fossil fuels and tropical deforestation. Conversely, carbon dioxide is dissolved in the oceans and absorbed by vegetation during photosynthesis.
Global Carbon Cycle (from Terrestrial Ecosystem Ecology Laboratory). Water vapor, which has the greatest greenhouse effect in the atmosphere, is released into the atmosphere from open water surfaces such as oceans and lakes through the process of evaporation and to a much lesser extent from land surfaces and vegetation by means of evaporation and evapo-transpiration. Water vapor experiences a change of state, from gas to liquid, through the process of condensation. Most water vapor is found in the troposphere. Its concentration is established through internal mechanisms of the climate system and is not appreciably affected in a direct way by human actions. However, if greenhouse gases added by man cause the planet to warm, additional evaporation from the oceans would lead to increased water vapor in the atmosphere, amplifying the greenhouse effect.
Global Water Cycle (from NASA ESE). Nitrous oxide is formed by numerous reactions of microorganisms in the oceans and soils. It is also produced by various anthropogenic actions that include industrial combustion, vehicle exhausts, the burning of biomass and the use of chemical fertilizers. N2O is destroyed in the stratosphere by photochemical reactions driven by sunlight. Methane is a very significant greenhouse gas. Current emissions of CH4 are primarily due to the growing of rice, the digestive processes of grazing cattle, the mining of coal and drilling of oil and natural gas deposits, and decomposition of natural wastes in landfills. Methane is destroyed in the troposphere through its reaction with free hydroxyl (OH) radicals: CH4 + OH -> CH3 + H2O Ozone (O3), which is produced naturally in the stratosphere, is mixed into the lower atmosphere in small quantities. When some oxygen molecules (O2) absorb solar ultraviolet radiation they split to yield two oxygen atoms. These freed atoms may then combine with remaining O2 molecules to form ozone: O2 + O -> O3 During the last century, some additional ozone has been produced near the surface by the action of sunlight on polluted air that results from emissions of motor vehicles, the burning of fossil fuels in power plants, and biomass burning. The main cause of ozone depletion in the stratosphere is reaction of the O3 with man-made chemicals like chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs, which are further discussed below). CFCs rise into the stratosphere from the surface and chlorine is released through reaction with ultraviolet radiation. Chlorine, in turn, reacts with the highly unstable ozone, causing its destruction. Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) have been used in refrigerants and aerosol propellants and have also been found in industrial pollution. They are composed of carbon, chlorine and fluorine molecules. CFC concentration steadily rose from the time of its development in the late 1920’s until production ended in January 1996. CFCs have the potential to significantly affect climate because of their considerable radiative forcing effects (hundreds to thousands of times greater than CO2) and century-long atmospheric lifetimes. Replacing CFCs are hydrofluorocarbons or HFCs, which also have a potent greenhouse effect, but do not have the atmospheric longevity of CFCs. |
|